North Spirit:
Travels Among The Cree And Ojibway Nations And Their Star Maps- REVIEW
John Kim Bell- recommends
Dr. Cora Voyageur - recommends
Reality
replaces romance
North Spirit: Travels Among The Cree And Ojibway Nations
And Their Star Maps
By Paulette Jiles
Anchor Canada edition 2003
391 pages, $21(sc)
Review by Joan Taillon
In 1973, Paulette Jiles left behind a failed relationship
in Toronto and accepted a CBC assignment to work in Big Trout
Lake, where she helped establish a radio station that would be
run by the local Aboriginal people. With a book of published
poetry to her credit and work in progress on another, and a much
greater body of publishing credits since, Jiles' precision with
language comes through in a lyrical and evocative first-person
account of her northern experience.
She
describes North Spirit as a book of creative non-fiction. Most
of the book's characters are composites. So is the fictional
community of North Spirit Lake, which is based on the real communities
of Big Trout Lake and Sandy Lake. The events in the book are
all true, the author says. North Spirit reads like a well-woven
memoir, for that is what it is, selected accounts from a significant
phase in an adventurous writer's life.
North Spirit is a lot more than that, however. Through Jiles'
eyes, the reader gets to see the effect of the dawn of modern
communications on remote communities and on Indian reserves in
particular. A sense of nostalgia may come upon the reader for
the traditional way of life that is vanishing in the sweep of
technological change.
While the old values of sharing and caring remain, the compromises
with the outsider culture are starkly evident. As television
and VCRs creep in, consumerism gets a foothold, and the old gatherings
for storytelling and family-centred entertainment decline. By
the 1970s, the mythology that has underpinned both the stories
and the beliefs of Indian peoples for eons is already fissured
and split. Here and there, the old people remember and relate
portions of their stories, and Jiles dutifully records them.
At the heart of Jiles' book, first published in hardcover in
1995, lies her fascination with the Star People and the night
sky, and the Ojibway and Cree legends reflecting differing cultural
beliefs about the constellations.
Anyone who has lived in the North will recognize that Jiles so
often gets the details right: the culture shock on both sides,
the daily interactions and interdependence of community life,
the self-reliance and stoicism and humor of northern peoples,
the seasonal transitions, the precarious balance of life and
death.
Where Jiles falters a bit is in the first chapters, in places.
There are a few too many speeches about the play she is writing,
which struck me as self-absorbed and boring. I wondered if she
had found it difficult to find a starting point for her tale.
In addition, sometimes the dialogue by Native people just does
not ring true-speeches there too-devices Jiles used to fold in
the necessary exposition, when the likelihood is that a word
or two, or a look, replaced a lot of the talk.
When Jiles describes something-a place, an incident-her voice
is a waterfall cascading over little stones, eddying, carrying
the reader deftly to a new experience, but the book would have
benefited from stronger character development throughout.
The other weakness I found irritating for a book that has been
reprinted several times is sloppy copyediting in the early pages,
starting with page one of the preface. Either that improved after
a few chapters, or my awareness of it was subsumed by a beautiful
story told by a writer of great skill.
John Kim Bell
-Founder & President,
National Aboriginal Achievement Foundation
Recommends:
Barney's Version
By Mordecai Richler
Knopf Canada-1997
I recommend the book because it is exquisitely written by
one of Canada's national treasures. It is a shame that due to
Mr. Richler's untimely death, we will never again have the pleasure
of reading another novel of such rich characters, wit and intellect.
Not only does one laugh aloud while reading this opus, it is
an experience that lasts well after the last page has been savored.
It is a story about a man's three marriages, his friendships,
children, business dealings and aging.
Dr. Cora Voyageur
-Sociologist,
University of Calgary
I am surrounded by books and must read as part of my job as
a university professor. To me pleasure reading means escapism
and using my imagination. I recommend the Outlander series.
I came across these gems when my daughter Carly told me about
this great historical fantasy she was reading. Trash I thought-looking
down my academic nose. I purchased the entire series (Outlander,
Dragonfly in Amber, Voyager, Drums of Autumn,
and Fiery Cross) as her birthday gift-hiding the fact
that Outlander was actually for me. Since then, these
books have become my guilty pleasure and I cannot put them down.
Diana Gabaldon tells the story of Clare Randall, a British Second
World War nurse who accidentally steps through a standing stone
and is transported back 200 years to rural Scotland where she
meets Jamie Fraser. Gabaldon weaves a tale of historical adventure
and romance that whisks the reader away to 18th century England,
Scotland, and United States. These books are well-written, intriguing,
and at times a bit racy. They are not for the faint of heart,
each running about 750 pages. This is escapist, pleasure reading
at its finest. Enjoy.